Twelfth Night

by Mothership on January 4, 2009

If music be the food of love, play on!

Thus goes the opening line from Shakespeare’s Twelfth Night.

Tonight actually is twelfth night and after taking down the decorations, dismantling the tree and putting away all the other Christmas paraphernalia, I served up an enormous roast chicken with all the trimmings for my eager family, some of whom were actually banging on the table, Henry VIII style with their spoons (One, as of course you guessed. Husband has better manners and merely shouts where is my supper). I fed them until their bellies were round and bulging and they were positively humming with satisfaction.  During the meal Husband declared that the pouring of a good glass of claret was a symphony to his ears, thus proving that the Bard made a mistake – clearly food is the music of love, not the other way around.

In the midst of our merriment and satiety, I was reminded of a man I encountered yesterday. Our lives touched only briefly but I have found it difficult to get him out of my head.

He stood by the off ramp, anxiously, politely holding a small sign.

HUNGRY TIMOTHY

was all it said.

It immediately caught my attention. The minimalism of it.
I have seen a lot of signs held up by the needy and indigent, as have you, and they range from the usual “homeless and hungry, please help” to “broke and trying to get to –“ or even occasionally the amusing and honest “need money for beer”. 

But this was different.  It was compelling in its use of his full first name – not a diminutive like Tim or Timmy, but the more dignified Timothy, and it just said what he was.

Hungry.

It was the Haiku of help-me signs.

He carried about himself a certain poise. Humble, but not humiliated. In need, but not needy.

He must  have been about my age, or perhaps a bit younger but weather beaten. His beard was neatly clipped and his clothes were tidy, if worn.  There was a sense of quiet desperation about him that I could sense from five cars away, though he was perfectly still and stood up straight with his shoulders back. I watched him look at the stopped traffic with pale, blue, unfathomable eyes. How many would look away? Many of us did.

If we make eye contact we are forced to admit that Hungry Timothy is a human being, and acknowledge him. And then we will have to give.  Because how can we not give to someone who is hungry when we are not? Most people are actually pretty generous, so it’s not usually giving that is a problem, it’s often some kind of harboured resentment towards those down on their luck.

I really don’t believe that people get there because they don’t want to work or because they’re lazy. I think it’s much harder to stand around begging for money than working for it. It’s actually like having a job selling your own pride to the world’s worst, most abusive boss and there are hundreds of them and no supervisor to go to when you get shat on.

So why do we feel such aversion?

Do we feel ashamed of our good fortune?

Or that they deserve it?

I am not sure. It’s a hard one to answer.

My father always hands out money to the homeless. He always has, as long as I can remember, even though he is not someone who generally gives to charity. I once asked him when I was a very young woman why he did it, did he really think it helped those people? He said that he didn’t know in the long term, but it assisted them in the moment when they felt most in need. And it also helped him.  I asked what he meant by that and he answered

“There but for the grace of God go I” 

He explained that he felt there was just a thin skein of good fortune that separated him, in his late model car, high flying job and many-roomed home from these guys sucking a bottle of Thunderbird on the street corner and it really wasn’t so very far to fall from grace. And perhaps on that terrible day that a person finds themselves at the bottom without a dime, someone may hand them a dollar and wish them luck.

He didn’t exactly spell it out, but I got the feeling that this was the closest that my very practical, atheist father is going to get to admitting to paying into a divine karmic insurance policy. Oh well, it’s all good – made perfect sense to me.

I dug a dollar out of my purse and I handed it to Hungry Timothy as I drove around the corner, wishing him all the best. He thanked me with simple dignity and our fingers brushed.

I looked for him later when I came to that intersection again, but he had moved on. I hope that he found some money, some food, some shelter, and that at least today he is not Hungry Timothy but perhaps Full Timothy.

And in the future I wish for him to be Warm Timothy, Employed Timothy, Laughing Timothy, Unafraid Timothy, Joyous Timothy. I wish for him not to have to hold a sign that defines him in the eyes of others just in order to survive from one day to the next.

I wish for him to be just Timothy. 

I wish things to be just for Timothy.

 

{ 14 comments }

1 Melike Bitlis-Bush January 5, 2009 at 5:09 pm

It is a coincidence that just this morning I “helped” another young lady at the corner of State Street and Five Points. She was very young and had no sign at all. But it was clear that she needed some help. $1 for us may be nothing for us but I am sure it makes a big difference for them. I just hope that they do not use it for drugs and/or alcohol.

2 YCC January 5, 2009 at 6:11 pm

Good read! What goes around comes around – good deeds don’t go unnoticed and come back around in good fortune when you might be in need of it. Good karma!!!

3 Michelle January 5, 2009 at 8:48 pm

Why is it so difficult to look these people in the eye? I need to figure this out for myself.

4 chattycat January 5, 2009 at 9:45 pm

what would really make things okay for people who beg for money? Is it up to the government to help them or do we have to help them out? I have heard a lot of them are mentally ill or have been abused. So how can we help beyond just handing out a buck? That might make us feel better but is it just for a bottle of beer? That doesnt make me feel better

5 Karen Delucchi January 5, 2009 at 10:31 pm

I know exactly why we can’t look them in the eye. Because they want something, and we don’t want to give it. Because they are in need, and we don’t know what to do to get them out of need. Because they make demands on us, and we don’t know if we are helping or enabling an addiction of some sort. Because they are, after all, human beings, but they are not acting in a way that is normal and comfortable for us. Because we are lucky, and they are not…and they make us feel guilty for our good fortune, as though we either don’t deserve it or should really not have it so well, if it means someone else does not.

6 Opal K. January 5, 2009 at 10:51 pm

Hungry Timothy is somebody’s baby. He’s somebody’s son. Once he was somebody’s darling and now none of us want to look at him. It is so sad that we forget that we are all just people who need love and care, and that we are not all able to give it as we are all frightened.

7 momofthree January 5, 2009 at 10:56 pm

He’s a man who made choices and his choice was to stand there and ask for money. Maybe he could have done something differently

8 Claire January 5, 2009 at 11:36 pm

very good read…i am also worried that the money actually will be spent on booze….one time in NY I handed a plate of food to someone and he rebelled as to why I don’t give him money…since then I am always in suspicion as to where that dollar goes..as it is certain these folks needs lots of help in many ways…good health care, a bath …a job ..

9 Jessica K January 6, 2009 at 9:32 am

I dont think anyone chooses to be there.
I think we react with anger, suspicion or hostility because we are all a couple of twists of fate away from that.
If you are concerned with how the money might be spent, give to an organization that is helping. At least you will be doing something to help.

10 KimB January 6, 2009 at 10:45 am

to compel me to walk a mile in Timothy’s shoes alongside you is the gift of realization of how truly blessed I am. touching, honest and beautiful. thank you.

11 hved72 January 6, 2009 at 11:58 am

I’m from a socialist country in Europe. There, no one needs to go hungry. People go hungry because they’ve spent all their money on something less sensible (like beer).
Here it’s different. I often feel guilty for not giving charity to the needy- we all need to do more.

12 Anne M January 6, 2009 at 12:00 pm

Thank you for keeping your eyes open – literally and figuratively. I realize how lucky I am that I have a myriad of choices available to me in my life -but that doesn’t mean others do.

13 akasheena January 6, 2009 at 7:24 pm

My politics are more liberal than most. However, I just don’t think giving people who are begging for money is the right answer. (The exception being the old and infirm.) Often, I think it just assuages the guilt of the giver. It’s a lot easier to do that than to volunteer your time or send $100 to an organization that teaches people to regain their dignity by taking care of themselves. I can’t imagine that life will really get better for them until they can. And don’t get me started on giving money to begging children in third world countries…

14 Daddy Daycare January 8, 2009 at 7:51 pm

Very thought provoking to be sure. It’s sad that the state of the world and the media that covers it forces us to believe the worst in others. One person does something wrong and now we all take our shoes off at the airport. We see the homeless and look past them. We worry any money we give may be spent fueling addictions. I’m no different. A kind word or smile is an open invitation for solicitation – so we’d rather pretend they don’t exist. Do I feel guilty for what I have? Sometimes – but I worked hard for it and I’m very grateful for the opportunities that I have had in my life. I’m not sure what the solution is. In the meantime – bless you Timothy may you find a road to self sufficiency.

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post:

Next post: