Disney Cashing In? Surely not!

by Mothership on April 20, 2009

I read today that Disney is releasing their first princess movie in over a decade and it will be making history by featuring their very first black princess.

How very shrewd of them, and how timely.

It is called The Princess and the Frog (a reworking of the classic fairy tale The Frog Prince )*, set in New Orleans in the 1920’s.  

Here’s the plot:
A prince named Naveen from the land of Maldonia,is transformed into a frog by the evil scheming voodoo magician Dr. Facilier. The frog prince asks a waitress named Tiana to break the spell by kissing him. However, the kiss doesn’t break the spell but rather makes Tiana a frog, as well. Together the two of them must reach the good voodoo priestess of the Bayou, Mama Odie, while befriending a trumpet-playing alligator and a hopelessly romantic firefly along the way.  

Warning!! SPOILER ALERT!!

Apparently, in the end Tiana will get to have both her career and her handsome prince.
Hurrah for progress, you CAN have it all!

My first thought is to wonder, anxiously,  if she’s set to lose at least one of them following the crash of ’29 and the subsequent depression, but probably not, because this is a fairy tale and they are going to live happily ever after despite racial discrimination, the terrible floods of ’37 and no breath of a civil rights movement for nearly forty years.

*I would like to point out that in the original Frog Prince, the heroine throws the frog against the wall with great force, she doesn’t kiss him, and it is that action causes him to turn into a prince. I WISH I had got that memo when I was a child, it would have saved me quite a few skanky boyfriends, but I digress..

I am trying very hard not to be hugely cynical about this post Obama move (surely no coincidence that this is also the year that black Barbie comes out?) and not see it merely as a giant KERCHIIINGGG! opportunity for Walt and co. to bring millions of people of colour the world over into the Disney marketing fold.

Yes, trying, but largely failing.

I am sure that it is hugely meaningful for African American girls to have some kind of fantasy princess representation out there in the mainstream culture where they have been sidelined for so long. However I so loathe the genre and all they stand for that I am wondering why this was the gift we had to give to this generation of children?

I don’t believe that a Disney film has the primary motive of teaching our little girls morality and ragtime, nor do I think that it’s from a noble place of historic significance that they decided to make Tiana African American.  You don’t need to be a rocket scientist to work out that the Obamas did their free market research for them..

“Why yes, I think the American public might be ready to accept a black princess, now and spend some coin on it.. What do you think, guys, now that every woman in the country is having secret fantasies about sex with Barack and Michelle is on the cover of People Magazine and Vogue and all..?”

The Frog Princess is undoubtedly going to be a box office smash, as all the princess films are, but far more importantly for the Disney cash registers it is going to sell untold billions in related merchandise to a market that will suddenly feel related to and embraced for the first time by Uncle Walt (who may be perceived by now to be more All-American than Uncle Sam himself.)

So, that will be several billion tons of Tiana sippy cups, acrylic ballgowns, plastic crowns, talking frogs,  t-shirts, bikes, balls, stickers, colouring books, pencils, chicken noodle soup, beach towels, earrings, crackers, fruit roll ups, knickers, diapers, etc. which will spend a short time with another little princess before it becomes landfill in a kingdom far away.

But that part is not Disney’s problem.

That part will be our little princesses’ problem when they are bigger and not living so happily ever after.

{ 17 comments }

1 Dan Miranda April 20, 2009 at 1:59 pm

Excellent points you make. Unfortunately Disney has made many mistakes (a la this project), but who knows maybe it will be a successful cash flow opportunity for them.

Dan Miranda’s last blog post..A Series of Questions To Be You, Your Best You

2 Dave April 20, 2009 at 2:19 pm

Whoa! Cynical. That film went into production over 3 years ago as far as I can remember, so has nothing to do with anything Obama related. And there have been plenty of princesses of colour (all admittedly very irritating) in past Disney films!

3 Mothership April 20, 2009 at 2:40 pm

Dan, there is NO DOUBT that this will be a successful cash flow opportunity. That’s all it ever is.
Dave: Point taken over the production time (although apparently she started out as a white princess and then it was changed later). There have been Disney princesses of colour,it’s true BUT they have not been part of the ‘romantic’ set who get to wear ballgowns etc. and more importantly they have specifically not been black. It has been interesting to note that as each racial demographic is represented, that has opened up a new marketing niche for Disney (Asian parents were markedly more open to the princess brand after Mulan came out, for instance) Still, there are few little girls who choose to dress as Pocahontas or Mulan. They all want the twirly dresses, and that is what this shrewd move is going to be about. It’s not about the movie, it’s about the merchandise.

4 The unreliable historian April 20, 2009 at 2:43 pm

What I am getting out of this is a distinct desire to get in my little time machine and chuck some frogs at some walls, and let the wall sort them out.

The unreliable historian’s last blog post..Running with Brooms- College Quidditch comes of age.

5 Kathy April 20, 2009 at 2:50 pm

Just a quick note re: black Barbie. I am 42, and I had a black Barbie when I was growing up, probably around 1975. If one is being released this year it’s certainly not a first.

6 Mothership April 20, 2009 at 2:54 pm

Thanks for that info. Kathy. My source was the Washington Post so I will alert them to their mistake! http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/04/16/AR2009041603139.html

7 The Mother April 20, 2009 at 4:01 pm

There are days when I am so very grateful that I have boys.

The Mother’s last blog post..Alcohol Awareness, The Mother Style

8 Jaime A. April 21, 2009 at 12:01 am

Oh dear – so torn….

Although my post-feminist self totally agrees with you view re: the cynicism and gender-nastiness that Disney is soooo very good at….when I was little (and presumably, my mother had had enough of me) I used to spend lots of weekends with my aunt, who lived in Orange County. She was a public schoolteacher, and thus the recipient of many free ticket books for Disneyland (this dates me terribly – it was before they had a one-ticket-per-day policy!)

Well, I grew up loving the Magic Kingdom, and I still feel all gooey about it, even now. And although I loved the princesses, it wasn’t until Belle came out that I identified with one of them (and by then I was certianly old enough to know better!!!) because not only did she have brown hair & brown eyes, but she loved to READ!!!!! That was the clincher for me :-)

Now that I have a little girl, what to do? Stay true to the principles that I know are “good for her”, or allow her a bit of fantasy princess-ness…maybe like chocolate: only a little bit and only on holidays?

9 nappyvalleygirl April 21, 2009 at 1:51 am

Get what you’re saying, but sometimes with corporations like Disney it’s a case of ‘damned if you do, damned if you don’t…’

Having said that, the picture of the princess in her green frock does look suspiciously like Michelle…..

nappyvalleygirl’s last blog post..Picture perfect

10 Maternal Tales April 21, 2009 at 3:14 am

Well it was bound to happen sooner or later. Shame it didn’t happen sooner and then it could be enjoyed without all the cynical attachments.

Maternal Tales’s last blog post..Childbirth and Sheep Farms

11 Liz@VioletPosy April 21, 2009 at 6:05 am

Chucking frogs against walls…hmmm now there is a version I need to track down for my daughter :)

Liz@VioletPosy’s last blog post..Small Gardening

12 Domestic Engineer April 21, 2009 at 3:10 pm

Well, at least Disney is becoming an equal-opportunity marketer!

13 Home Office Mum April 21, 2009 at 9:45 pm

You see now my sons would love a film where people throw frogs against a wall, although them turning into princes would be far more disappointing than them going splat in an icky mess. Loved the line about the Obama’s doin Disney’s free market research….

Home Office Mum’s last blog post..Reflections and preparations

14 Mothership April 22, 2009 at 9:29 am

The Mother: Yes, I am glad my son will not be caught up in this, but then we will just have to avoid Star Wars instead..
Jaime: Here’s where my total hypocrisy is unveiled: Will probably take Four to ‘Biz-neyland’, as she calls it, for her 5th birthday as she is totally desperate to go where all her pals go. I will loathe it but she will love it. However, on the princess front, there are plenty of opportunities to indulge in this fantasy without resorting to Walt Disney’s version of it. Particularly like The Princess Knight by Cornelia Funke. Buy it if you haven’t got it already. http://www.amazon.com/Princess-Knight-Booklist-Editors-Choice/dp/0439536308
NappyValleyGirl: Disney is late to the party with this one. And they still all have bodies like playboy bunnies – ugh!
Maternal Tales: Even if we took the colour issue out of this, we’d still be left with all the other objectionable crap, IMHO. I think the fact that they are making the princess black is a colourwash for all the other bollocks that comes with it. But, I do wonder if any of the black community are going to be offended by the voodoo mama aspect? Is that racial stereotyping or necessary to the plot? I don’t know. I am not black or American and these are not my sensitivities..
Liz: You will find that version in any of the Grimm Fairy Tales books (or just Wiki it!)
Domestic: Ah yes! Disney, the great equal opportunities Capitalist – take everybody’s money equally, thanks for that! I wonder if they’ll fill everybody’s landfill equally too? I doubt it somehow (NIMBY)
Home Office Mum: Aren’t there films with frogs going splat in an icky mess already? Or is that just human beings?:)

15 Iota April 22, 2009 at 3:14 pm

The thing about Disney princesses that gets me most is that the message always seems to be “be true to yourself, look deep in your heart and whatever anyone else thinks, stick to your own dreams”, so in theory it’s all good stuff. But in practice, the message is “be true to yourself (as long as you’re just like every other little girl), stick to your own dreams (as long as they’re the ones we’ve given you, to do with being a princess and being beautiful)”.

Have you read the book “Princess Grace” by Mary Hoffman? Have a look on Amazon. You’ll love it, I’m sure. It’s deeply counter-cultural. The message is “be proud of yourself, express yourself (even if that means not being a girly princess, which is also fine, but you can do better if you have a bit more imagination)”.

Iota’s last blog post..Saints

16 jodiemiller April 27, 2009 at 10:24 pm

Gosh, this is the first I’ve heard of it! Obviously Disney marketing hasn’t hit mainstream Australia.

I reckon Queen Latifah is the ultimate rolemodel for teenage girls. Sweetheart, why be a princess when you can be a Queen?

jodiemiller’s last blog post..Indulging myself

17 Veronica October 21, 2011 at 2:59 pm

Do you mind if I quote a couple of your posts as long as I provide credit and sources back to your site? My blog site is in the very same area of interest as yours and my users would certainly benefit from a lot of the information you provide here. Please let me know if this ok with you. Cheers!

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post:

Next post: