The night before last was the Kindergarten end-of-school play; “Down on the Farm”, in which my beloved Six had a speaking part as a donkey.
Actually, it was wonderful as all of the children had a speaking part and they sang some very sweet songs, hilariously finishing up with “Country Road, Take me Home“.
All thirty six children – that’s both Kindergarten classes combined – trooped into the assembly room and lined up on the steps of the stage in twos and threes according to which character they were playing. Most of the children were animals, but there were a couple of scarecrows, two farmers and three ‘farmers’ wives’.
Just to let you know, there are six boys in the whole of Kindergarten. They were assigned the scarecrows and farmer parts. Oh. And two who aren’t such great talkers got to be turkeys.
Each animal described its job on the farm in rhyme, with each child assigned a line. It was very sweet!
Six and her fellow donkey:
“I am stubborn and I never behave, I always make the farmer rave”
(visions of agricultural students with smileyface t-shirts going “Aciiiiiiiiid!”)
But the Farmers’ Wives! Three little girls in aprons and headscarves:
“I cook and I clean and I sweep all day, sometimes I get to tidy hay”
WTF?
Husband and I exchanged a raised eyebrow although nobody else seemed bothered.
Um, last time I checked we were not encouraging women to think of themselves as being defined by their menfolk.
HELLO? THE WORLD IS FULL OF WOMEN FARMERS!
This strange hybrid of 1950’s housewife and rural idealisation was very unsettling and, in my view, limiting and damaging to my curious, wild daughter not to mention the other thirty impressionable girls.
Of course it was just a play, and yes, it was just cute, and I know, it was just full of chatty sheep and turkeys, but still. Even the talking livestock were allowed their own identity and some kind of farm-specific work.
The farmers’ wives lives were just domestic servitude transplanted to the country with a side of straw.
I want my daughter to think she has more to offer than a dustpan and brush, and that life (and agriculture) has more to offer her.
So I wrote to the teacher.
Dear Mrs. X, and Mrs. Y
Wasn’t that the most fantastic performance? All of the children did wonderfully and it was so marvellous to see them all shining on the stage, confident and happy after a year of learning and nurturing under your expert tutelage.
You have done so very much for us all. Thank you, thank you, thank you!
One thing, though, that did jump out for me and my husband were the lines of the ‘farmers’ wives’.
Why do they have to be cooking and cleaning as their primary role? And why do they have to be farmers’ wives in the first place? Why can’t they have their own identity and also just be farmers? (I don’t remember the cows being referred to as the bull’s wives)
This might seem like a small point, but to our small children, it might actually loom rather large, especially compounded over time.
Growing up as a child of the 70’s and 80’s – the era of political correctness – meant that a lot of gratuitous sexism was eradicated, or at least suppressed, and I thought that it really was going to be possible to grow up as an equal to men and by the time I raised my own children there would be no question of gender inequality. However, since then there seems to have been an alarming backlash, and now I find that more than ever there is casual and thoughtless sexism running rife and unquestioned through our daily lives. The media becomes increasingly appearance obsessed, plastic surgery is on the rise for all age groups, female politicians are judged on their appearance rather than their policies, and we’re still earning 79c on the dollar as compared to men.
Thanks to you, the children have all been learning about seeds and plants and how they grow this year (I have had photosynthesis explained to me, somewhat condescendingly, a few times). Six has taken this in very enthusiastically and we have many little plants growing at home, and are observing them keenly, and she regards herself as somewhat of a gardener, if not a farmer.
I’m hoping she won’t start to think she should be cooking and cleaning instead.
Once again, though. I thought you two did a brilliant job with the play. I would not speak up about this if I didn’t think it was worth saying, and it in no way detracts from the amazing job that you have done all year, and with this fantastic production.
I was pleased and proud to be there.
Kind regards,
Mothership.
I received a very short, polite reply some 24 hours later thanking me for my views and saying that if they did the play again (which presumably they will as they requested donations for the costumes to be kept for future years) they would take this into account and that they had been trying to think of alternative names for ‘farmers’ wives’.
I restrained myself from writing back and offering my services as playwright and lyricist although I am fairly brimming with fabulous ideas. I intuited, with my almost psychic emotional antennae, that they wanted me to STFU so I graciously left it at that and when I went in yesterday for my usual hour of volunteering in class we all pretended that I hadn’t said anything.
*if you listen closely, however, you can hear the muffled scream of Mothership’s brain – HOW ABOUT JUST FARMER? HOW ABOUT AN EASY RHYMING COUPLET COLLECTING EGGS AND FEEDING CHICKENS? OR SHEARING SHEEP OR SOWING SEED? OR FIGHTING LAWSUITS AGAINST MONSANTO?*
Six heard me loud and clear,though. Poor child doesn’t have a choice 😉
{ 16 comments }
Go Mothership!! Quite right too. Things don’t change unless people speak up. At my childrens last christmas play they had some of the girls in bikini tops and grass skirts wiggling around for Herods viewing pleasure. One of them had to say something like, ‘Oh dear he’s not in a very good mood today. We’d better give it our best shot if we’re going to cheer him up!’ If my daughter had been old enough to take part I would have said something. I certainly wouldn’t have let the school put her in that position.
.-= Gappy´s last blog ..Do You Ever Miss Your Old Life? =-.
Oh I LOVE this – absolutely spot on and so very funny at the same time.
And I bet the majority of the parents just thought it was ‘so cute’ and never even questioned the apportioning of roles and ‘gender-specific’ tasks…
I’m on your side, farmer.
LCM x
.-= London City Mum´s last blog ..Still life? Try this for starters =-.
I agree entirely – and I definitely would have noticed.
After all, even the Lego farm kit comes with a female farmer these days – she is in dungarees and a hat, and definitely not mean to be cooking apple pie in the kitchen!
.-= nappyvalleygirl´s last blog ..Please understand me…. =-.
Go woman go! Very depressing that it’s two (5?) steps forward and one (6?) steps back. BUT: A lutta continua (the struggle continues) and you’re a born leader to reverse the backlash! Your daughter’s blessed having you as a Mother.
Woo hoo, way to go! I’m so glad you wrote a letter and let them know your views. Hopefully they’ll change it for next time and that’s one less message the little girls will get that they belong in the kitchen.
.-= Noble Savage´s last blog ..The assassination of Iggle Piggle =-.
As a mother of one girl (Aged 17)among boys,currently with a FARMER AS A BOYFRIEND..one word- Fanbloodytastic!
.-= Northern Snippet´s last blog ..My life in Bars =-.
Dear MTFF, your daughter is very lucky to have you for a mother. You are so right, all subsistence agriculture (particularly in Africa) is handled by women, they are the food gatherers, the herders, the works- and yet they are considered by this school as merely farmers’ wives? I thought Pakistan and Afghanistan were criticised for promoting such stereotypes…hmmmm. Brava Brava Brava to you for writing to the teacher. Love, s
.-= shayma´s last blog ..Chicken Brochette in the Pakistani Manner =-.
I do love it when you get a bee in your bonnet – this post made me laugh. You and you alone will turn Six’s school around its just going to take time.
When I was in Indonesia last year, I watched women cook the breakfast, do the washing and then off to do the farming all while looking after the children. The men…well they were drinking tea and playing dominoes.
.-= So Lovely´s last blog ..rainy Los Angeles =-.
My six year old is going to win America’s Next Top Model – so we are aiming really high…it is, at least, a little more realistic than her plan to become a Princess. Ho hum.
.-= veryanniemary´s last blog ..Brave New Me Update =-.
Oh my, very good for you for writing. I don’t think that would happen in San Francisco, but have et to enter kindergarten so will has to wait a see. As you say, in this day and age the notion of a farmers wife sitting cleaning is bizzare. With 30girls to 6 boys there should be plenty of chances for the girls to take on any role they can think of.
.-= GEekymummy´s last blog ..booby trap =-.
Good for you and very well said. How infuriating it must have been to sit and watch it. Just caught up on your letter to Shayma too, very moving both x
.-= Knackered Mother´s last blog ..Have we met before? =-.
And an award for you over at mine
http://londoncitymum.blogspot.com/2010/06/brilliant-blogs.html
LCM x
.-= London City Mum´s last blog ..Brilliant blogs =-.
Stumbled upon your blog by accident and all I can think is, I hope I’m nearly as cool as you when I become a mother! Kudos to you for encouraging your schools to break away from antiquated stereotypes 🙂
Bloody right MTFF! And good for you for piping up and saying something. I get all mealy mouthed and English about the whole thing.
On another note, 36 Kindergartners singing “Country Road, Take Me Home” makes me teary-eyed just thinking about it. Had I been there, I’d have been in floods. Hope you made it through okay.
Love,
Miss W
.-= Miss Whistle´s last blog ..22 and counting =-.
MTFF,
I am totally with you on this. I was lucky enough to go to a very feminist high school, and it never crossed my mind (or that of my collagues) that we could be anything less than what we wanted to be, whether it was a space engineer, a doctor, an army captain, a primary school teacher, a chef, the prime minister or a stay at home mum. In hindsight my mother also banned all the things you do- the magazines and a certain level of broadcast media (we had radio 4 and blue peter) although I never realised it at the time, and I am so grateful for this. Keep up the good work! Your daughter will thank you for it, eventually.
However I’m also going to be annoyingly pedantic about the world being full of women farmers- in the less developed world perhaps this is the case, but alas not in the USA and Europe. Farmers wives there are on the whole still farmers wives, (albeit an integral part of the family business, driving diversification etc), and only very rarely ‘farmers’. A lot of this is due to socialisation of farmers’ children by the farmers themselves: the boys are brought up the be farmers, the girls to be something else, like a farmer’s wife. A girl taking on her father’s farm is still a great exception, nowhere near the rule. (I’m going on about this because this is one of the themes of my PhD…. I’m sure that there will be lots of commenters to prove me wrong but I’m talking about widescale sociological studies, not anecdotal evidence ) . This is something which comes from within the farming community- so whilst not a great example to your daughter’s class of gender equality, the play could probably be considered 100% spot on in terms of reportage…..(especially with the donkey, I would say).
We have a long way to go!
DP
Thank you all for the comments. I thought it was important to speak up and it’s nice to know that there are other people in agreement as well as the sheeple who said and did nothing at school.
DP, your thesis sounds fascinating, and you may be quite right about attitudes in Europe and the USA. However I stand by my former statement of the WORLD being full of women farmers. As Shayma (who has considerable professional expertise in this area) pointed out, subsistence agriculture is largely handled by women. The World Bank and UN reports going back decades would concur.
As for accurate reportage, I am yet to meet a talking turkey, or scarecrow (outside of Oz, that is).
Thanks for stopping by!
Comments on this entry are closed.